Legislative Analyst's Office, December 2000

LAO
Recommended
Legislation
Transportation

Transportation

Conduct Ongoing Transportation Needs Assessment

Recommendation

Require a statewide transportation needs assessment every five years.

Rationale

The first step in identifying a solution to a problem is identifying the scope of the problem. Yet, when it comes to transportation, there is currently no requirement that Caltrans or any other state entity assess and report on the state's overall transportation needs on a regular basis.

While Caltrans and regional transportation planning agencies (RTPAs) must regularly update funding and scheduling documents, such as the State Transportation Improvement Program and the State Highway Operation and Protection Program, these documents provide no information about unfunded needs. Similarly, RTPAs are required to adopt 20-year long-range planning documents under both state and federal law, but these documents are not compiled to provide a view of the state's needs as a whole.

LAO Reference

Please see California Travels: Financing Our Transportation,
May 2000, page 54.

LAO Contact

Rebecca Long: 445-5921

Transportation

Authorize High Occupancy Toll Lane Pilot Project

Recommendation

Create high occupancy toll (HOT) lanes as a pilot program.

Rationale

Single occupant vehicles make less efficient use of state highway capacity than carpools or buses. Charging drivers for the cost of driving, through the use of tolls, can encourage people to use alternatives to driving alone. In this way, tolls can serve as a type of user fee which can result in a more efficient use of the existing capacity on the state highway system.

In order to determine whether a more widespread use of road pricing is advisable, the Legislature should establish a pilot program to authorize HOT lanes. The HOT lanes allow single-occupant vehicles to buy access into the carpool lane for a fee, and thereby make greater use of any excess capacity in the carpool lane.

LAO Reference

Please see HOV Lanes in California: Are They Achieving Their Goals?, January 7, 2000, page 20, and After the Transportation Blueprint: Developing an Efficient Transportation System,
March 5, 1998, page 12.

LAO Contact

Rebecca Long: 445-5921

Transportation Revenues

Fund Transit Rolling Stock

Recommendation

Amend the State Constitution to permit the use of gas tax revenues for transit rolling stock.

Rationale

The State Constitution (Article XIX) restricts the use of fuel tax revenues (gas and diesel taxes) to (1) construction, maintenance, and operation of roads and highways or (2) construction and maintenance of mass transit guideways and facilities (mainly rail tracks). Transit rolling stock (mainly railcars and buses) is the only type of transportation capital outlay that currently cannot use fuel tax revenues under Article XIX.

Modifying Article XIX to allow fuel tax revenues to be used for transit rolling stock would allow greater flexibility in the use of fuel tax revenues for the most cost-effective transportation projects.

LAO Reference

Please see After the Transportation Blueprint: Developing and Funding an Efficient Transportation System, March 5, 1998, page 3.

LAO Contact

Dana Curry: 445-5921

Transportation

Broaden Criteria for Advancing STIP County Shares

Recommendation

Broaden the eligibility criteria for advancing State Transportation Improvement Program (STIP) funding to counties.

Rationale

Under current law, the regional share of the STIP is divided into county shares based on population and state highway miles. For a variety of reasons, most counties do not program the full amount of their share of project funds. The California Transportation Commission is authorized to advance the shares of county funds that are on reserve and loan them to other counties that have exhausted their share and identified projects in need of funding. However, current law limits the use of advances. As a result, the restrictions unnecessarily limit the use of state transportation funds, causing them to sit idle, rather than be put to work immediately.

LAO Reference

Please see our 2000-01 Analysis, page A-51.

LAO Contact

Rebecca Long: 445-5921


Return to 2000 Recommended Legislation Table of Contents

Continue to 2000 Recommended Legislation General Government

Return to LAO Home Page