California's traditional jobs report suggests the state added 15,000 jobs in December, while a hybrid measure that has more closely tracked final jobs data suggests a smaller increase of 6,000 jobs. The state's unemployment rate rose to 5.5 percent, as the labor force grew slightly but fewer workers reported being employed.
Our post provides an updated snapshot of housing affordability in California. Over the last few years, we have seen a rapid increase in California housing costs, led by the dramatic increase in the costs of purchasing a home. Monthly costs for a newly purchased home are about $2,600 higher than they were just a few years ago, driven both by increases in home prices between 2020 and 2022 and an increase in mortgage rates since 2022.
The rapid increase in mortgage rates in 2022 has also left most existing homeowners "locked-in" to mortgages with rates significantly lower than currently available. More than 80 percent of California homeowners have mortgage rates under 5 percent, compared to current rates of about 7 percent. These homeowners face a significant additional financial cost to moving, further limiting the number of homes available for sale.
Recent PIT withholding covering November, December, and early January came in roughly $1.5 billion (8 percent) higher than last year. This trend is roughly in-line with the strong withholding growth seen since the beginning of summer. Our best assessment of underlying cash trends (adjusted for holiday season timing issues) is that withholding is running about 3 percent ahead of projections included as part of the 2024-25 Budget Act.
November data shows inflation in the US and California is trending upwards but remains lower than post-pandemic highs. Relative to the US as a whole, housing prices have grown less in California since 2020 but utility prices have grown more.
Since mid-2022, the state's monthly jobs survey has tended to overestimate actual employment growth. The data revision from the first quarter of 2024 gave some hope that this pattern was correcting, but the newest incoming data show the monthly survey again overstating employment. Specifically, the most recent match to administrative records shows the survey overestimated job creation from March through June this year by roughly 150,000 jobs (preliminary survey gain of 68,000 relative to matched net loss of 78,000 jobs).
Our new forecast for 2024-25 cannabis tax revenue is $653 million, somewhat lower than the May Revision forecast of $695 million.
California's technology companies, including giants like Apple, Google, Nvidia, and Meta, are some of the most valuable companies in the world and support thousands of high-paying jobs in the state. Many employees at these companies receive equity pay, such as stock options and restricted stock units, in addition to their base salary. As we first pointed out a year ago, state income tax withholding on equity pay has grown notably in recent years due to the AI boom in asset prices for these companies. With updated data from early 2024, we now believe withholding from these sources reached about 10 percent of all income tax withholding during the first half of 2024.
U.S. retail sales have grown 1.1 percent over the last 3 months and 2.8 percent over the last 12 months. Retail sales growth has outpaced inflation substantially over the last 3 months, but only slightly over the last 12 months.
U.S. retail sales have grown 1.7 percent over the last 3 months and also 1.7 percent over the last 12 months. Retail sales growth has outpaced inflation over the last 3 months, but not over the last 12 months.
U.S. retail sales have grown 0.9 percent over the last 3 months and 2.1 percent over the last 12 months. Retail sales growth has outpaced inflation over the last 3 months, but not over the last 12 months.
Our new cannabis tax revenue estimates are similar to the revenues anticipated by the 2024-25 budget package.
Updated Forecast In Line With Budget Assumptions. Our updated forecast is basically unchanged from last month and remains in line with Budget Act revenue assumptions. That being said, we are only two months into the new fiscal year and it is virtually certain the revenue outlook will change in the coming months. Ultimately, it would not be surprising if revenues ended up $20 billion higher or lower than our estimate for 2024-25 and $35 billion higher or lower for 2025-26.
U.S. retail sales have grown 1 percent over the last 3 months and 2.7 percent over the last 12 months. Retail sales growth has outpaced inflation over the last 3 months, but not over the last 12 months.
Recently released figures from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) show that California continues to lose taxpayers to other states. The state has long had annual net outmigration (more people moving out of California to other states than moving in) but the trend has increased since 2020. Looking ahead, should the heightened trend of net outmigration continue, it could drag down annual income tax revenue growth below its long-term average.
U.S. retail sales have grown 0.1 percent over the last 3 months and 2.3 percent over the last 12 months. Over both periods, sales have grown more slowly than inflation.